Comments on Gumbo's stuff

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Day 28 Anyone else still writing songs? this is the result of trying to listen to too many mixes in one day. Sometimes it's just easier to record something else.
Uploaded
Gumbo's avatar
Gumbo said

thanks for the comment, MEJ I feel the same way sometimes but Hey! could you be more specific about what you think needs to be different?

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Day 28 Anyone else still writing songs? this is the result of trying to listen to too many mixes in one day. Sometimes it's just easier to record something else.
Uploaded
Guest said

Don't publish this. Not ready MEJ

Gumbo's avatar
Final version it needs a fiddle but it has a mandolin, a chicken banjo and some excellent backing vocalists my third demo for RPM 2011 The cat's in the window and the rabbit's in the hutch goat's in the meadow just a-chewin on the…
Uploaded
moschell's avatar
moschell said

You know... this is exactly the way I picture your life. Love this one.

Gumbo's avatar
Final version it needs a fiddle but it has a mandolin, a chicken banjo and some excellent backing vocalists my third demo for RPM 2011 The cat's in the window and the rabbit's in the hutch goat's in the meadow just a-chewin on the…
Uploaded
Keith Landry's avatar
Keith Landry said

Listening to this track right now with my daughter... Outstanding track!!! She says "it's silly, I like it, it makes me giggle!"

Gumbo's avatar
Final Version If in doubt write more songs with Kazoo solo! and heckling! this is as close as i got to some hokum jug band
Uploaded
Sandy Gritt's avatar
Sandy Gritt said

What a hoot! Love it!

Gumbo's avatar
I'm finally happy with this track - v1 was too much of a nothing song and it's been bugging me all the way to the last night of the challenge. 1 more to mix
Uploaded
Sandy Gritt's avatar
Sandy Gritt said

this is so good...catchy rustic goodness!

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Day 28 Anyone else still writing songs? this is the result of trying to listen to too many mixes in one day. Sometimes it's just easier to record something else.
Uploaded
Guest said

Stormin' album! Totally loved it. I'd be begging for swapsies if I had one to swap this year.

Gumbo's avatar
EDIT final version now posted and the page turning is gone but i left this intro as is in case anyone is reading the comments. Does anyone read the comments? or the intro? i turn a page somewhere in the middle of all this - you'd think i would…
Uploaded
thetworegs's avatar
thetworegs said

it had got a hold of me by 15 sec... oooh yeh the wind did blow......just like the rest....a fantastic album.... if i was king ..... i would give you a tital...arise Sir Gumbo.....master of guitar and vocal

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Guitar, mandolin and voice. this doesn't fit with my rpm project AT ALL so i may not use it but i like the way it came out. I recorded the music for Bethan Mathis' RPM project but she didn't have time to use it (her album is…
Uploaded
Guest said

Failsafe of lovely.

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Every so often when i'm thinking of something else a western song pops up as if there is a soundtrack to a movie running in the back of my head. I might have to gather em all up into a playlist some day. track nine, or at least…
Uploaded
Guest said

Brilliant, Gumbo! Just love your effortless, genius song-writing! (Apologies for the short comments, am cooking and shamefully not listening with headphones.)

Gumbo's avatar
Final Version If in doubt write more songs with Kazoo solo! and heckling! this is as close as i got to some hokum jug band
Uploaded
Guest said

Classic Gumbo!

Gumbo's avatar
Final version RPM 2011 - my first track recorded and the opening track for the CD A kind of Old Time gospel number, which, if you listen to those pre-war guitar playing preachers, are virtually indistinguishable from blues. Except for the lyrics…
Uploaded
Guest said

Settling in for Gumbo's RPM album...definitely in for a treat! Gumbooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Day 28 Anyone else still writing songs? this is the result of trying to listen to too many mixes in one day. Sometimes it's just easier to record something else.
Uploaded
Dirty Spirits's avatar
Dirty Spirits said

i held off listening to too many of your demos so i could just sit down and have my mind totally blown at one time. and it is. your one of most talented fellows doing this free music stuff. your last two rpm's are in a master class that has few members.

Gumbo's avatar
Final Version If in doubt write more songs with Kazoo solo! and heckling! this is as close as i got to some hokum jug band
Uploaded
Dirty Spirits's avatar
Dirty Spirits said

this has the quintessential "Gumbo" sound. love it.

Gumbo's avatar
Final version An unaccompanied song about bedtime. Not a lullaby though. Oh no! What does anyone think of the 'cat's moustache' line - it seems like that's a make or break call right there and i like it when i read it but it's hard to sing without…
Uploaded
Dirty Spirits's avatar
Dirty Spirits said

very skillfully done and oh so soulful.

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Day 28 Anyone else still writing songs? this is the result of trying to listen to too many mixes in one day. Sometimes it's just easier to record something else.
Uploaded
Gumbo's avatar
Gumbo said

LOL Bethan - that is turning out to be true ....

Gumbo's avatar
Final version Day 28 Anyone else still writing songs? this is the result of trying to listen to too many mixes in one day. Sometimes it's just easier to record something else.
Uploaded
Guest said

Oh Gumbo, you know there is no such thing! Ha, you are the best!

Gumbo's avatar
EDIT final version now posted and the page turning is gone but i left this intro as is in case anyone is reading the comments. Does anyone read the comments? or the intro? i turn a page somewhere in the middle of all this - you'd think i would…
Uploaded
Guest said

Oh my, superb playing! Love your tone also. Totally smooth, Gumbo! One of those songs that gives you that "this is a classic" feeling instantly.

Gumbo's avatar
Final version I wanted to have a banjo fiddle tune but i still haven't learnt to play either instrument, so this is my famous 1 string banjo technique, with mandolin and guitar. It's style is inspired by meeting Morgan O'Kane and Ferd 4 last…
Uploaded
Guest said

*swooooooooooon* Great music, Gumbo! 1 string or otherwise!

Gumbo's avatar
I'm finally happy with this track - v1 was too much of a nothing song and it's been bugging me all the way to the last night of the challenge. 1 more to mix
Uploaded
Guest said

I think you were blown there from N'orleans! Cracking track!

Saved!